Some Beautiful Carnival Glass Pieces

My experiece with Carnival Glass is limited based on just owning a few insulators that caught my eye over the years. I pictured my PYREX CD 233 to the left. The color is quite nice.

I did a Peachridge post earlier on Glasshouse Hat Whimsies (Read: Toppin’ it off with a few Glasshouse Hat Whimsies) and came across a Carnival Glass hat whimsey that I really liked and included in the article. I see this glass in the many antique shops I visit but usually bypass because of my hunt for Civil-War era glass.

Because of my lack of knowledge and desise to know more, I took a few moments to review Carnival Glass history on various web sites and have put together a few pictures of earlier and later pieces for comparison.

My passion for glass leads me in many directions sometimes, and away from my area of expertise. We need to broaden our horizon with glass history. I honestly can appreciate contemporary glass, early american glass, bottles, depression era glass and hope to visit the Getty Villa Museum soon to really see some ancient glass. Read more: Maryo Visit to the Getty Villa

Carnival glass has been known by many other names in the past: aurora glass, dope glass, rainbow glass, taffeta glass, and disparagingly as ‘poor man’s Tiffany’.

CD 118 No Embossing, This unique style is one of the rarest Hemingray carnival glass insulators produced. Of the handful still around, most are found with damage. This particular piece has been repaired. - Hemingray.info

Carnival glass is moulded or pressed glass, always with a pattern and always with a shiny, metallic, ‘iridescent’ surface shimmer. The keys to its appeal were that it looked superficially like the very much finer and very much more expensive blown iridescent glass by Tiffany, Loetz and others and also that the cheerful bright finish caught the light even in dark corners of the home.

Exquisite Carnival Glass Vase

Both functional and ornamental objects were produced in the carnival finish and patterns ranged from simple through geometric and ‘cut’ styles to pictorial and figurative. A wide range of colours and colour combinations were used but the most common colours accounted for a large proportion of output, so scarce colours can today command very high prices on the collector market.

Carnival glass has been known by many other names in the past: aurora glass, dope glass, rainbow glass, taffeta glass, and disparagingly as ‘poor man’s Tiffany’. Its current name was adopted by collectors in the 1950s from the fact that it was sometimes given as prizes at carnivals, fetes & fairgrounds. However, that can be misleading as people tend to think that all of it was distributed in this way but evidence suggests that the vast majority of it was purchased by the housewife to brighten up the home at a time when only the well off could afford bright electric lighting.

Some carnival glass is still produced today although in very small quantities. At the height of its popularity in the 1920s huge volumes were produced and prices were low enough for the ordinary home to afford.

Starting at the beginning of the 20th Century Carnival Glass was eventually produced on every continent except Africa and Antarctica but largely and initially in the U.S.. All the major European glass making centres except Italy produced some and it was very popular in Australia.

Carnival glass gets its iridescent sheen from the application of metallic salts while the glass is still hot from the pressing. A final firing of the glass brings out the iridescent properties of the salts, giving carnival glass the distinct shine it is known for.

History

Carnival glass originated as a glass called ‘Iridill’, produced beginning in 1908 by the Fenton Art Glass Company (founded in 1905). Iridill was inspired by the fine blown art glass of such makers as Tiffany and Steuben, but did not sell at the anticipated premium prices and was subsequently discounted. After these markdowns, Iridill pieces were used as carnival prizes.

Iridill became popular and very profitable for Fenton, which produced many different types of items in this finish, in over 150 patterns. Fenton maintained their position as the largest manufacturer and were one of very few makers to use a red coloured glass base for their carnival glass. After interest waned in the late 1920s, Fenton stopped producing carnival glass for many years. In more recent years, due to a resurgence in interest, Fenton re-started production of carnival glass until its closure in 2007.

Most U.S. carnival glass was made before 1925, with production in clear decline after 1931. Some significant production continued outside the US through the depression years of the early 1930s, tapering off to very little by the 1940s.

Often the same moulds were used to produce clear and transparent coloured glass as well as carnival versions, so producers could switch production between these finishes easily according to demand.

Colors

Carnival glass was made in a wide array of colors, shades, color combinations and variants. More than fifty have been formally classified. These classifications do not go by the surface colors showing, which can be even more varied, but by the ‘base’ colours of the glass before application of the iridizing mineral salts.

In order to establish the base color you have to find an area of the item which had no mineral salts applied, which is usually the base, and hold the item up to the light in such a way that you can see through that area. This is usually easy enough to do, but it can still be difficult for the inexperienced to differentiate the exact base color between the many possibilities as there are often only subtle differences, as well as variations.

The final (post doping) surface shades vary also according to the depth of base color as well as any special treatments and the type and amount of salts used. This last variable caused significant variation to occur even between batches of what should have been, essentially the same colour or colour-way. This happened most frequently in early production but to such an extent that collectors now differentiate between these items, describing the degree of iridescence showing.

The most popular color for Carnival Glass is now known by collectors as ‘marigold’ although that name was not in use at the time. Marigold has a clear glass base and is the most easily recognisable carnival color. The final surface colors of marigold are mostly a bright orange-gold turning perhaps to copper with small areas showing rainbow or ‘oil-slick’ highlights. The highlights appear mostly on ridges in the pattern and vary in strength according to the light.

Marigold carnival glass is the most frequently found color and in general commands lower prices in the collector market. However, variants of marigold such as those based on ‘moonstone’ a translucent white and ‘milk glass’ an opaque white base, can be more sought after. Other base colors include; amethyst, a reddish purple; blue, green, red and amber. These basic colors are then further delineated by shade; depth of color; color combinations such as ‘amberina’; color pattern such as ‘slag’; special treatments such as ‘opalescent’ and finally luminescence such as that given off by ‘vaseline glass’ or ‘uranium glass’ under ultra violet light (blacklight).

Shapes

Carnival Glass was produced in a wide variety of items, from utilitarian to the purely decorative. Even within groups of items a variety of shapes can be found with further variation in edging and bases as well as different treatments of the basic shape while still malleable fresh from the mould. For example, of three items coming from the same mould, one could be left as is, another folded inwards and the third splayed outwards. Edge styles varied from plain to include frilled after moulding, or pie crust, furrowed or bullet, as a part of the mould pattern.

The basic items produced included bowls, plates, vases, jugs or pitchers and tumblers but many other more specialised items of tableware were made also. These included large centre piece items such as jardinières and float bowls as well as smaller useful items such as butter dishes, celery vases and cruet sets. In smaller numbers and less often found are items to do with lighting or associated with smoking and those designed solely for show as ornaments such as figural sculptures or statuettes.

Patterns

Carnival glass was produced in large quantities in the US by the Fenton, Northwood, Imperial, Millersburg, Westmoreland, Dugan/Diamond, Cambridge, and U.S. Glass companies as well as many smaller manufacturers. Competition became so fierce that new patterns were continually being developed, so each company ended up making a wide range of patterns of most types adding up to a panoply of choice. By selling sample pieces to carnival fair operators, it was hoped that a winner would then go on to purchase further items in the same or a similar pattern. Pressed glass ‘blancs’ were bought in and iridized by third parties as well.

Different and in many cases highly distinctive carnival glass patterns were designed and by non-US makers, most notably by Crown Crystal of Australia, now famed for their depiction of that continent’s distinctive fauna and flora in their glass. Sowerby (England) are notable for their use of swan, hen and dolphin figural pieces in carnival finish as well as pieces which have figural parts such as bird figured legs. There is even a figural boat. Of their non-figural production, the strong, bold and easily recognizable ‘African Shield’, ‘King James’ and ‘Drape’ patterns provided a good canvas for shimmering carnival colours.

German production of carnival was dominated by the Brockwitz glassworks, with mainly geometric patterns which take their cues from cut glass. Other major European makers included Inwald (Czechoslovakia), Eda (Sweden) and Riihimäki (Finland). These again produced cut glass styles and simple geometrics with a few floral patterns. However, the most distinctive continental European patterns are probably the similarly styled ‘Classic Arts’ & ‘Egyptian Queen’, produced by the Czech Rindskopf works, sporting stained bands of figures over a very simple geometric form in a very even marigold.

In other parts of the world most notable are the Argentinian Cristalerias Rigolleau for their innovative and highly distinctive ash trays and Cristalerias Piccardo for their highly desirable ‘Jewelled Peacock Tail’ vase.  Finally, the Indian Jain company should not go unmentioned, notable for their distinctive elephant, fish and hand figural sections incorporated into the body of trumpet shaped vases and for their desirable and highly complex goddess vases.

Carnival glass is highly collectible. Prices vary widely, with some pieces worth very little, while other, rare items command thousands of dollars. Examples of carnival glass can be easily found in antique stores, and there is a very active market for it on eBay.

Identification of carnival glass is frequently difficult. Many manufacturers did not include a maker’s mark on their product, and some did for only part of the time they produced the glass. Identifying carnival glass involves matching patterns, colors, sheen, edges, thickness, and other factors from old manufacturer’s trade catalogs, other known examples, or other reference material. Since many manufacturers produced close copies of their rivals’ popular patterns, carnival glass identification can be challenging even for an expert. [source: Wikipedia]

Blue Carnival Glass Rooster Candy Dish - A beautiful blue iridescent carnival glass rooster candy dish that has been in the family for decades. My Mom, being the bird lover she was had this proudly displayed in one of her curio cabinets. The colors are just so gorgeous with finely tuned details specifically around the feathers and base of the piece. - Poetic Shutterbug

Pitcher and three tumblers from the Paneled Dandelion pattern by Fenton. The pitcher is 12 1/2" tall and each tumbler is 4" tall. Exotic pressed leaf design, with colors that change depending on the angle of the reflected light. Sometimes these pieces look blue, other times green, and sometimes marigold! - Replacements, Ltd.

Vintage Northwood Grape & Cable Standard or Table Water Set, 7 pcs, circa 1900 - 1940 - Bonanza

Carnival Glass Dish

The first featured carnival glass piece from our museum is a 3-toed bowl from the Grape and Cable pattern by Fenton Glass. 5” tall and 8 1/2" in diameter. Large leaves and a rope metaphor are featured as part of the design motif for this rare piece of art glass. - Replacements, Ltd.

Good Luck Carnival Glass Bowl detail - Ruby Lane

Northwood PEACOCK AT THE FOUNTAIN carnival glass pitcher, c. 1915 - Silver Quill Antiques

Fenton WATER LILY Vintage Marigold Carnival Glass Footed Sauce Bowl. Little marigold carnival glass sauce dish or bowl made by Fenton in the Waterlily pattern aka Lotus and Poinsettia. The dish is ruffled and stands on three ball feet. Beautiful iridescence more concentrated in the folds and center of the dish. Measurements: 6" wide and 2-1/4" tall - Ruby Lane

Vintage Indiana Glass covered canister manufactured in the Grape Harvest pattern. - The canister measures approximately 9 inches tall with the lid on. The opening across the top measures almost 6 1/4 inches. The container displays beautiful metallic iridescence on the teal blue base glass. - Jane K. Cleland

Collection of ten better pattern Carnival glass bowls - Auction of Estate Antiques 2004

About Ferdinand Meyer V

Ferdinand Meyer V, President, Federation of Historical Bottle Collectors, is a native of Baltimore, Maryland and has a BFA in Fine Art and Graphic Design from the Kansas City Art Institute and School of Design. Ferdinand is the founding Principal of FMG Design, a nationally recognized design consultation firm. Ferdinand is a passionate collector of American historical glass specializing in bitters bottles, color runs and related classic figural bottles. Ferdinand is married to Elizabeth Jane Meyer and lives in Houston, Texas with their daughter and three wonderful grandchildren. The Meyers are also very involved in Quarter Horses, antiques and early United States postage stamps.
This entry was posted in Carnival Glass, Depression Glass, Dinnerware, Glass Companies & Works, Glass Makers, History, Insulators, Vases and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply